FundRaiser Blog

The FundRaiser Software Blog is an excellent resource for nonprofit organizations looking to learn more about fundraising, donor management, membership management, and much more.

Segmenting Lists

Segmenting Lists

Dear Kim,

I am about to take the plunge. For years I’ve listened to many fundraisers stress the importance of segmenting your donor lists. For a variety of reasons including laziness, being too busy, and poor software, I have not yet done this.

But there are other reasons that I never see anyone mention. I just processed a donation from someone whose last gift was in 2003. He was responding to the newsletter. This has happened many, many times in the years I’ve worked here. Had I gotten around to segmenting, I would probably have left this person off the newsletter list and might have missed this donation.

So, I’ve been loathe to actually remove anyone who is still alive from the mailing list without their request to do so. This also leaves me in a quandary about how to segment and what categories to use.

Signed,

~Leaving them off without leaving them out

Dear Leaving,

I am an enormous fan of segmenting and my experience is that, when it is done right, it saves time and results in greater donor retention (which can be measured) and greater donor happiness (harder to measure but very important).

Segmenting basically means trying to meet the donor where they are. For example, organizations that have large galas or other kinds of big events often find that there are people who only go to those events and do not respond to any other requests for money. In fact, if the organization doesn’t have the event one year, those people don’t give at all. So, I wonder, why send them extra appeals? Just invite them to the event and keep them on your e-newsletter list.

Some people only give once a year. No matter how often you ask them, they give once. And they may be complaining about you to their friends, “they ask me all the time.” So, suppress their names for multiple mailings. On the other hand, some donors (and may their numbers increase) give every time they are asked. We might add an extra appeal for that segment or invite them to become monthly donors.

One segment of donors I think about are those who are working low wage jobs who really stretch to make a donation of $35 or so. I don’t think they assume their money is being used to keep people on the mailing list who don’t give or who only give every few years. For that reason, I don’t worry about taking someone off the list who gives very infrequently.

But let’s look at how segmenting could help in the case of the person who responded to your newsletter after 12 years of silence. From now on:

  • Take all the people who have not given in two years or more and send them a friendly letter saying, “We love having people on our mailing list who want to be on it, but feel badly if we are sending you mail you really don’t have time to look at. Can you use the enclosed card to let us know whether you want to stay on the list or not?” The card has three choices, “YES” “NO, I wish you well but have too much to read already” and, “You can move me to your e-list and will keep up with your wonderful work on-line.” I am assuming the donor you reference would have sent this card back. But there are people who are getting your newsletters who don’t want them–no offense—and they will use this as a chance to tell you that. The majority of people who haven’t given won’t send back the card because they throw away everything you send them. SO, now a segment arises: take them off your mailing list for one year, then write to them and say words to this effect, “Did you miss us? We missed you and would like to have you back on our list. Please contribute.” You want people on your list who have indicated they want to be on it, and I would say have indicated it more frequently than one gift every 13 years.

Good luck,

Kim Klein

Originally published in the Grassroots FundRaising Journal. FundRaiser users can subscribe at a special rate of $30/year by entering is "$30" in the coupon code field on the second page of the subscription process.

Read more about how FundRaiser Software can help you with your fundraising:

FundrRaiser's core features

In Remembrance of Larry Weaver, the voice of FundR...
New Year, New Codes

Related Posts

Wait a minute, while we are rendering the calendar
donor slip reports donor preferences Facebook merge notes corporate sponsors case study direct mail mailing Crowdfunding Campaign new donors FundRaiser Basic Volunteer module merge fields fundraising donor advised funds updates Groupings relationship tracking monthly giving SYBUNTS donor contact information product news in honor of donations planned giving segmenting donors holiday giving ticket sales importing csv donor recognition planning how-to videos social media annual campaign publicity materials correspondance customer portal budget premiums passwords happiness backing up data disaster relief office recurring gifts Snow Birds password protection Personalizing features repeat donors overview Constant Contact Donor Portal FundRaiser Spark mode code donor prospects major donors LYBUNTS foundations communications board members arts membersip benefits nonprofit fundraising operating systems donor profile data conversion welcome packet fundraising letters In-Kind gifts Excel brick campaign salutation community arts nonprofits gift acceptance policy role of nonprofits PayPal phoning donors membership programs user spotlights giving levels appeal letters moves management event management donor targeting Reminders Company culture Importing Data NCOA processing annual maintenance plan change of address updating the Ask Alternative Addresses data entry training Cloud letter raffle Network for Good donor general membership benefits how to handle auction gifts grants follow up endowment campaign #GivingTuesday ticketsales campaign management donor retention rate upgrade tribute gifts Codes announcements volunteering campaign spare fields government grants gift notes field tech tip transparency animal rescue appeal community supported gardens giving history anonymous donors holiday new nonprofit Reporting to IRS new features community broadcasting Congratulations Task List banquet security spreadsheets thank you letters look and feel donor relations mission driven donor attrition word processor solicitors auction flash sales texting donors Thanksgiving email customer service memorial giving increasing giving amounts Resiliency building donor relationships entering auction gifts National Change of Address motivation grassroots campaign donor engagement online donations data analysis capital campaign accounting software vacation Tickles personalizing letters New Year correspondence donation history legacy giving understanding giving trends small donations donor loyalty operational costs letter templates donor retention alumni End of Year Letters development director on site training adding personal notes to letters large donations tax summary letters new version donor source upgrading donors donor attrition rate training tip holiday letters FundRaiser Hosted GoFundMe project prospects custom page pictures Thank You GivingTuesday gift entry user interface technical support Facebook campaign charity golf tournaments ROI lapsed donor targeted mailings volunteers major gift prospects add ons support motivation code online donations pledges new leadership advanced tab

Connect With Us

  800-880-3454 ext 3
  Email Us
  Request More Information
  Monday-Friday
      8:30AM-5:30PM CST

Customer Portal Login Form

   

The customer portal is unavailable. If you need support please reach out to support@fundraisersoftware.com Thank you.

 

  User Name:
  Password:

If you are not sure about your Customer User Name, please call 800-543-4131 and we will be able to help you.

Or you have lost your password, Request Password